Christmas is coming, and you probably know someone who is hard to buy a present for. You might be tempted to buy them a gift voucher. Can we suggest you think again? Unfortunately, gift vouchers are a really bad idea. We know, we know – we sound like the Grinch. But let us explain.
You’ve probably heard of the Nobel Prize. This year’s peace prize was awarded to an Australian organisation, founded in Melbourne 10 years ago: the International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons. Well done to all involved!
The Nobel Prize is also awarded for economics. The 2017 award went to an American economist named Richard Thaler. Thaler is a ‘behavioural economist’ – which means that he studies the way people think about their money. If you ever get the chance, read some of his stuff or listen to a podcast. He is a hilarious man.
Thaler is best known for identifying a phenomenon known as ‘mental accounting.’ Mental accounting is where people link a specific dollar with a specific purpose. In doing so, they forget that money is fungible. Fungible is a fancy word that essentially tells us that ‘any dollar will do’ – you do not need to use a specific dollar to pay a particular expense.
Unfortunately, people frequently dedicate ‘specific’ money to a specific purpose. Thaler demonstrated this by asking people two questions. In the first question, Thaler presented the following situation:
You have paid $10 for a paper ticket to the movies. As you arrive at the cinema, you realise that you have lost your ticket. The ticket was not registered. If you wish to see the movie, you will need to purchase another ticket and pay another $10. Would you do this?
Less than half of the people, in this case, said that they would buy another ticket. Having lost their ticket, more than half of the people would skip the movie. Thaler then developed a second question which went along the following lines:
You are going to the cinema and you will buy your ticket when you arrive. When you arrive you discover that you have lost a $10 note. A ticket to the movies will cost $10. Will you still purchase a ticket and watch the movie?
In the second case, almost 90% of people said that they would still buy a ticket and watch the movie. Only 12% of people skipped the movie.
Thaler points out that there is no difference between losing a $10 note that will let you buy a ticket to get into a cinema and losing a $10 ticket that will also get you into the cinema. In each case, you have lost $10, and it will cost you another $10 to watch the movie. But people treat a $10 ticket and a $10 note differently – even when they are both intended to be used for the same purpose.
So, what’s all this got to do with gift vouchers? As we said above, gift vouchers are irrational. They perform the same function as cash, but they are much more restrictive. For example, if you spend $50 to buy somebody a gift voucher, often that voucher will expire within a particular period. What’s more, the voucher can only be used in a specific store. It is more restricted than the cash that you used.
Basically, a gift voucher represents a loan to the retailer. The purchaser gives the retailer money, but the retailer hasn’t given the purchaser anything yet. It is up to the recipient to decide whether the ‘loan’ is repaid by using the voucher. Not surprisingly, many retailers try to avoid repaying these loans by making it difficult to use their vouchers. For example, few retailers will give change when somebody uses a voucher. A retailer might issue a $50 gift voucher, but if a person spends $48, the retailer does not give them $2 change. Instead, the retailer says that the customer can only use that $2 towards the purchase of something of equal or higher value. The total spend will now be more than $50. The retailer says that they will only repay the loan if the recipient spends more than they borrowed. Try that one on with your bank!
Gift vouchers make money the opposite of fungible. Gift vouchers force recipients to apply mental accounting.
But there is hope. A family we know cottoned on to this when considering how to give young friends a birthday present. Lots of kids give each other vouchers – kids love shopping, after all. So, this family created its own ‘voucher’ on a piece of A4 paper. It was nicely coloured in, and it promised, in big bold letters, to be the “best voucher in the world.” It would be accepted everywhere, would never expire and if you did not spend it all, you could keep the change.
Then they stuck a $20 note to it.
Food for thought this Christmas!